Former U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice is the chairwoman of the Commission on College Basketball.
Imagine all the time and money spent to establish an NCAA Commission on College Basketball. The NCAA even created a logo for the group, and last week released a 61-page series of recommendations to “restore the trust and confidence in college sports.â€
Some of it was good. I liked the part about placing a school that cheats on a five-year probation, and forbidding it to receive any of the riches from the NCAA Tournament. I also liked the part about effectively banning a cheating coach for life.
I applaud the commission’s admission that the NCAA enforcement division is antiquated. It said: “the investigative and enforcement functions were designed for a simpler time. As a result, it has little credibility with the public. The NCAA and its member institutions have been unable to adequately deter or punish bad behavior.â€
And there was this: “The environment surrounding college basketball is a toxic mix of perverse incentives to cheat.â€
Well, no kidding.
The commission used a lot of big words and long paragraphs, but there was no grand solution. No way to effectively deal with agents, shoe companies, the sinister AAU travel-ball system, the NBA’s one-and-done arrangement or to shut off the underground economy that, among other things, threatens to blow up Arizona’s 30-year run as a basketball power.
Over seven months, some of the most respected names in the game’s history —ÌýDavid Robinson,ÌýGrant HillÌý²¹²Ô»åÌýMike MontgomeryÌý— met with commission chairÌýCondoleezza RiceÌýand others with impressive credentials inside college sports.
It said: “By the time the 2018-19 season tips off, the NCAA will adopt a series of bold legislative, policy and structures changes that will profoundly alter the college basketball landscape.â€
That’s not going to happen any time soon — or perhaps ever.
In advance of the report, the National Association of Basketball Coaches (NABC) sent an email to all the coaches suggesting they give “unequivocal support†to the commission’s recommendations. They even gave them a bullet-point list of talking points to include in their public statements. Predictably, UA coachÌýSean MillerÌýdid not make a public comment on the recommendations.
Ultimately, the basketball commission fell back on academics.
It said: “We believe that the answer to many of college basketball’s problems lies in a renewed commitment to the college degree as the centerpiece of intercollegiate athletics.â€
That may be the way Yale and Harvard do it, but it is not the way Duke, North Carolina, Arizona, Kansas and the game’s heavy-hitters are going to do it.
The NCAA’s Commission on Basketball has completed its job and gone home. Nothing really changes.

